Poptick can be caught using the Snak Trap.Initially, Poptick is just a small kernel and is too small be be caught by anything. Get the nearby Scorpenyo’s attention so it launches flames towards you. An easy way to do this is to drop your Snak Trap on the ground and it will immediately set it on fire. While you’re on fire, run towards the Popticks to set them on fire, as well.
Once the fire goes out on the Poptick, it will pop into a large piece of popcorn and begin bouncing around. Lure it away from the Scorpenyo with chocolate and cheese and into your Snak Trap to catch it.